| 2024 | Landon Bull-Rockridge | Trae Brickner-Peoria Christian; Landon Bull-Rockridge; Caleb Cunico-Rockridge; Hunter Froman-West Hancock; Braden Holthaus-Macomb; Cooper Knowles-West Hancock; Jackson McNeff-Brown County; Malachi Persinger-Peoria Christian; Wesley Robertson-Illini West; Gavin Walder-Peoria Christian; Drew Watson-Macomb |
| 2023 | Landon Bull-Rockridge | Hank Alvey-Illini Bluffs; Keauntrey Barnes-Farmington; Landon Bull-Rockridge; Ian Case-Macomb; Dion Doyle-Macomb; Tyler Heffren-Eureka; Carson Klemme-Rockridge; Nick Moore-Camp Pt Central; Drew Paben-Camp Pt Central; Lewis Siegfried-West Hancock |
| 2022 | Tyler Heffren-Eureka | Hank Alvey-Illini Bluffs; Keauntrey Barnes-Farmington; Landon Bull-Rockridge; Nolan Deitrich-Illini West; Isaac Genenbacher-Camp Pt Central; Tyler Heffren-Eureka; Luke Jacquot-West Hancock; Nick Moore-Camp Pt Central; Logan Morse-Farmington; Danny Stephens-Southeastern |
| 2021 | Tyler Heffren-Eureka | Tate Fullerton-Brown County; Trevor Heffren-Eureka; Tyler Heffren-Eureka; Nate Henry-Rockridge; John Ross Hess-Lewistown; Breiton Klingele-Liberty; Caden Mainland-Macomb; Nick Moore-Camp Pt Central; Logan Morse-Farmington; Corbin Rutledge-Farmington; Connor Watson-Macomb |
| 2020 | No Tournament Held - Covid | |
| 2019 | Nate Henry-Rockridge | Ryan Adolphson-Abingdon-Avon; Sam Allen-Macomb; Drake Hammel-West Hancock; Trevor Heffren-Eureka; Nathan Hendricker-Brown County; Nate Henry-Rockridge; Ben Martin-Farmington; Landon Obert-Liberty; Coltin Quagliano-Wethersfield; Jaden Rutledge-Farmington |
| 2018 | Drake Hammel-West Hancock | Ryan Adolphson-Abingdon-Avon; Cade Beekman-Lewistown; Payton Dooley-West Hancock; Drake Hammel-West Hancock; Ben Higgins-Macomb; Lane Ippsensen-Camp Pt Central; Jaden Rutledge-Farmington; Cam Scott-Illini Bluffs; Jamony Skinner-Monmouth-Roseville; Keegan Zimmerman-Eureka |
| 2017 | Logan Dorethy-West Hancock | Ryan Adolphson-Abingdon-Avon; Jarod DePriest-Farmington; Logan Dorethy-West Hancock; Darian Drake-Brown County; Carter Fayhee-Macomb; Kennedy Gooding-Illini West; Drake Hammel-West Hancock; Lane Ippensen-Camp Pt Central; Riley Langford-West Hancock; Cam Scott-Illini Bluffs |
| 2016 | Cooper Smith-Canton | Taylor Bruninga-Illini Bluffs; Carter Fayhee-Macomb; Carson Frakes-Rockridge; Eric Higgs-Farmington; Lucas Ketcham-Canton; Korbyn Personett-Pittsfield; Nick Reel-Pittsfield; Cooper Smith-Canton; Ben Stipp-Abingdon-Avon; Gentry Whiteman-Rockridge |
| 2015 | Gentry Whiteman-Rockridge | Taylor Bruninga-Illini Bluffs; Logan Dorethy-West Hancock; Carson Frakes-Rockridge; Sam Gillen-Monmouth-Roseville; Grant Hannant-Macomb; Will LeGrande-Lewistown; Korbyn Personett-Pittsfield; Cole Wellman-Liberty; Gentry Whiteman-Rockridge; Reed Wolfmeyer-Liberty |
| 2014 | Bryan Heath-Rockridge | Nolan Ard-Illini West; Bryan Heath-Rockridge; Jacob Billeter - Macomb; Justin Burdess-Lewistown; Nate Kennell - Metamora; Josh Dixon-Metamora; George Foust-Illini Bluffs; Taylor Heimann-Camp Pt Central; Colton Mellinger-Illini West; Korbyn Personett-Pittsfield |
| 2013 | Ethan Happ-Rockridge | Zach Glison-Abingdon-Avon; Ethan Happ-Rockridge; Bryan Heath-Rockridge; Martel Hunter-Monmouth-Roseville; Joe Kennell-Metamora; Nate Kennell-Metamora; Blake Lowderman-Macomb; Devon Rings-West Hancock; Hunter Rhodes-Canton; Tate Taufer-Eureka |
| 2012 | Martel Hunter-Monmouth-Roseville | Tianen Chen-Metamora; Jared Entwistle-Illini Central; Zach Gilsan-Abingdon; Jackson Grieves-Metamora; Brody Gronewold-Illini West; Paxton Harmon-West Hancock; Bryan Heath-Rockridge; Martel Hunter-Monmouth-Roseville; Jared McCunn-Eureka; Trayvon Smith-Monmouth-Roseville. |
| 2011 | Dalton Hoover-Pittsfield | Evan McGaughey-Illini West; Nick Heille-Macomb; Alex Gustafson-Pleasant Plains; Paxton Harmon-West Hancock; Dalton Hoover-Pittsfield; Trayvon Smith-Monmouth-Roseville; Alex Walter-Camp Pt. Central; Justin Volk-Brown Co.; Martel Hunter-Monmouth-Roseville; Jackson Grieves-Metamora; Jared Dehm-Metamora; Brody Gronewold-Illini West. |
| 2010 | Dalton Hoover-Pittsfield | Gage Beekman-Lewistown; Michagel Berg-Midwest Central; Jordan Fouts-Canton; Nicholas Heille-Macomb; Zac Main-Camp Point Central; Tyler Thorman-Macomb; Kyle Heck-Metamora; Brad Hamilton-Pittsfield; Evan Mcgaughey-Illini West; Dalton Hoover-Pittsfield. |
| 2009 | Jordan Fouts-Canton | Kyle Heck-Metamora; Danny Harman-Illini Central; Ryan Runge-West Hancock; Alex Roberts-Macomb; Jordan Fouts-Canton; Logan Harris-Pleasant Plains; Jacob Schmudlach-Illini West; Tyler Thorman-Macomb; Bradley Hamilton-Pittsfield; Justin Rollet-Canton; Ian Gaskill-Midwest Central; Matt Putrich-Canton. |
| 2008 | Tyler Harris-Western | Seth Wickert-Macomb; Davis Hendrickson-Macomb; Tyler Harris-Western; Logan Harris-Pleasant Plains; Ian Gaskill-Midwest Central; Brent Burrows-Lewistown; Jacob Schmudlach-Illini West; Andy Brackett-Abingdon; Quinton Hatfill-Lewistown; Will Carr-West Hancock; Christian Schultz-Pleasant Plains. |
| 2007 | Ben Gillen-Monmouth-Roseville | Ben Gillen-Monmouth-Roseville; Nick Andersen-Abingdon; Brian Thompson-Monmouth-Roseville; Clayton Hatfill-Lewistown; David Bergschneider-Pleasant Plains; Brian Flaharty-Lewistown; Matt Buren-Macomb; Ben Kearse-Warsaw/Nauvoo-Colusa; Evan Baietto-Pleasant Plains; Jacob Schmudlach-Illini West; Cory Bishop-Lewistown |
| 2006 | Matt Buren-Macomb | Matt Buren-Macomb; Ben Gillen-Monmouth-Roseville; Josh Watznauer-Farmington; Clayton Hatfill-Lewistown; Ben Pratt-Macomb; Corey Gruber-Abingdon; Matt Goedeke-Farmington; Eric Grant-Monmouth-Roseville; Josh Babb-Brown County; Luke Bavery-Warsaw/Nauvoo-Colusa |
| 2005 | Matt Buren-Macomb | Matt Buren-Macomb; Brock Edris-Carthage; Mark Lautz-Rock Falls; Tyler VanVleet-Macomb; Anthony Rivera-Illini Central; Josh Babb-Brown County; Josh Watznauer-Farmington; Nathan McNeely-Monmouth-Roseville; Douglas Edwards-Carthage; Zach Stuaan-Bushnell-Prairie City. |
| 2004 | Brock Edris-Carthage | Skyler McKinley-Carthage; Phillip Peugh-Rock Falls; Brock Edris-Carthage; Tyler Schrick-Illini Central; Greg Siepel-Farmington; Riley Scott-Rock Falls; Jeremy Ball-Canton; Evan Birch-Illini Central; Shawn March-Camp Point Central; David Bryant-Macomb; Tommy Keith-Abingdon. |
| 2003 | Wes Emberton-Canton | Wes Emberton-Canton; Joe Womble-Pittsfield; Nick Metzner-Macomb; Blake Mishler-Metamora; Matt Koster-Lewistown; Matt Brown-Farmington; Kennan Yelliot-Pittsfield; Isaiah Johnson-Rock Falls; Josh Coward-Rock Falls; Greg Siepel-Farmington; Ry Colwell-Abingdon |
| 2002 | Chad Cox-Macomb | Kevin Buckert-Hamilton; Travis Scott-Illini Central; Colt Jones-Abingdon; Chad Cox-Macomb; Aaron Sparks-Metamora; Wes Emberton-Canton; John Havens-Lewistown; Ryan Smith-Canton; Brandon Pirtle-Canton; Chris Wisslead-Southern |
| 2001 | Nate Koster-Lewistown | Colt Jones-Abingdon; Nate Koster-Lewistown; Chad Cox-Macomb; Ryan Welker-Farmington; Garret Grimm-Macomb; Jason Svejda-Hamilton; Greg Buelt-Warsaw; Zane Beekman-Lewistown; Brandon Grimsley-Illini Central; Chris Wisslead-Southern |
| 2000 | Mike Fitch-Pittsfield | Dan Adams-Metamora; Evan Arnold-Illini Central; Brad Arthur-Abingdon; Chad Cox-Macomb; Mike Fitch-Pittsfield; Jay Johnson-A-C Central; Nate Koster-Lewistown; Luke Lunt-Macomb; Tyler McCurry-Abingdon; Jake Sottos-Monmouth |
| 1999 | Barry Welsh-Abingdon | Evan Arnold-Illini Central; Brady Barke-Pittsfield; Tyke Bohanan-Canton; Luke Lunt-Macomb; Tyler McCurry-Abingdon; Rob Sollenberger-Farmington; Jake Sottos-Monmouth; Josh Svejda-Hamilton; Barry Welsh-Abingdon; Rhett Wierzba-Farmington |
| 1998 | Jason Edwin-Warsaw | Jared Brown-Abingdon; Jason Edwin-Warsaw; Matt Froman-Warsaw; Ryan Jaquot-Warsaw; Brian McNeil-Quincy Notre Dame; Seth Nelson-Farmington; Jimmy Sanderson-Pittsfield; Jake Sottos,
Monmouth; Barry Welsh-Abingdon; Rhett Wierzba-Farmington |
| 1997 | Seth Nelson-Farmington | Brad Bergman-Illini Central; Tom Clardy-Farmington; Dustin Carrier-Pittsfield; Scott Coykendall-Farmington; Matt Froman-Warsaw; Chris Herrera-Macomb; Brian McNeil-Quincy Notre Dame; Seth Nelson-Farmington; Eric Sandholm-Rochelle; Chris Schutte-Quincy Notre Dame |
| 1996 | Tarice Bryson-Stephen Decatur | Justin Bryant-Knoxville; Tarice Bryson-Stephen Decatur; Dan Buelt-Warsaw; Taurus Cook-Stephen Decatur; Bill Heisler-Warsaw; Arthur Jackson-Macomb; Seth Nelson-Farmington; J.D. Onken-Illini Central; Jonas Petty-Pittsfield; Michael Wilder-Stephen Decatur |
| 1995 | Jamie Reel-Pittsfield | J.C. Alexander-Canton; Brett Bohanan-Canton; Tarice Bryson-Stephen Decatur; J.L. Doubet-Farmington; Bill Heisler-Warsaw; Jason Reinhart-Pittsfield; Kris Stoneking-Abingdon; Craig Wear-Warsaw; Michael Wilder-Stephen Decatur; Jamie Reel-Pittsfield |
| 1994 | Raam Jani-Macomb | Trevor Hiel-BPC; Raam Jani-Macomb; Matt Knollenberg-Illini Central; Mark Personett-Pittsfield; Jamie Reel-Pittsfield; Ryan Sparks-Payson-Seymour-Kris Stoneking-Abingdon; Casey Veenhof-Macomb; Ben Wierzba-Farmington; Marty Worsely-Macomb. |
| 1993 | Brad DuBois-Metamora | Chip Borly-Abingdon; D.J. Cook-Monmouth; Brad DuBois-Metamora; Marc Gamage-Macomb; Jason Jacquot-Warsaw; Raam Jani-Macomb; Kurt Meister-Hamilton; Darren Monroe-Hamilton; Kyle Tudeen-Midwest Central; Matt Walker-Macomb. |
| 1992 | Aaron Zobrist-Metamora | Brad DuBois-Metamora; Brad Froman-Warsaw; Chad Jones-Canton; Paul Lenz-Payson-Seymour; Kurt Meister-Hamilton; Steve Owen-Abingdon; Clay Richardson-Farmington; Jamie Sweeting-Pittsfield; Kyle Tudeen-Midwest Central; Aaron Zobrist-Metamora. |
| 1991 | Bill Bavery-Warsaw | Steve Bishop-Canton; Bill Bavery-Warsaw; Brad Crow-Warsaw; Kris Figge-Warsaw; Ryan Kramer-Midwest Central; Paul Lenz-Payson-Seymour; Tim Rueschel-Camp Point Central; Larry Serven-B-PC; Jamie Sweeting-Pittsfield; Aaron Zobrist-Metamora. |
| 1990 | David McGinnis-Illini Central | Tony Baker-Pittsfield; Chad Benedict-Illini Central; Mark Dick-East Peoria; Brian Feezel-Pittsfield; Corey Hanbeck-Metamora; Troy Martin-East Peoria; David McGinnis-Illini Central; Matt Rader-Canton; Tim Reuschel-Camp Point Central; Kevin Rhodes-Canton. |
| 1989 | Ty Margenthaler-Macomb | Aaron Allen-Northwestern; Tony Baker-Pittsfield; David Bess-Pittsfield; Ty Margenthaler-Macomb; Matt McLaughlin-Macomb; David McGinnis-Illini Central; Alex Miller-Macomb; Greg Orendorff-Orion; Kevin Rhodes-Canton; Brent Walker-East Peoria. |
| 1988 | Derek Banta-Payson-Seymour; Fred Serven-Bushnell-Prairie City | Derek Banta-Payson-Seymour; John Hill-Pittsfield; Mike Kelley-Monmouth; Rob Louthian-B-PC; Ty Margenthaler-Macomb; Roy Miller-Pittsfield; Kevin Rhodes-Canton; Scott Schaub-East Peoria; Fred Serven-B-PC; Todd Teel-B-PC. |
| 1987 | Ty Margenthaler-Macomb | Brad Dietrich-Payson-Seymour; Troy Fischer-Pittsfield; Chris Hutt-East Peoria; Ty Margenthaler-Macomb; Chad Price-Macomb; Roger Rivera-Mason City; Bart Rogers-Hamilton; Doug Swan-Manito-Forman; Gary Wilson-Northwestern. |
| 1986 | Shannon Pritchard-Canton | Corey Akers-Rock Island Alleman; Jon Grzanich-Canton; Eric Guenther-East Peoria; Mike Kayvan-Hamilton; Paul Meinhardt-Hamilton; Willie Miller-Hamilton; Jay Murphy-Canton; Shannon Pritchard-Canton; Rick Reed-Pittsfield; Gary Wilson-Northwestern. |
| 1985 | Steve Rothert-Warsaw | David Berberet-Mason City; Rob Fahnestock-Canton; Todd Hardy-Warsaw; Jeff Hayden-Pittsfield; Greg Johnson-Monmouth; Matt Margenthaler-Macomb; Steve Myers-B-PC; Paul Petty-Pittsfield; Steve Rothert-Warsaw; Tony Vincent-Brown County. |
| 1984 | Tim Fischer-Pittsfield | Todd Anderson-East Peoria; Brad Beenders-Mason City; Bill Cartwright-Princeton; Tim Fischer-Pittsfield; Jeff Hayden-Pittsfield; Matt Margenthaler-Macomb; Tyler Patterson-Monmouth; Paul Petty-Pittsfield; Robert Rice-St. Benedict; Doug Robbins-Princeton. |
| 1983 | Bob Siedel-Abingdon | B.T. Aleshire-Hamilton; David Billeter-Northwestern; Phil Fogliani-Lewistown; Dan Kipling-BPC; Neil Mayfield-QND; Dean Pfeiferling-Hamilton; Bob Siedel-Abingdon; Scott Slocum-East Peoria; Tim Whittaker-QND; Vic Wildenradt-East Peoria. |
| 1982 | Dan McCaughey-Quincy Notre Dame | Kirk Ankrom-Jacksonville; Troy Brown-Macomb; Mike Casteel-Pittsfield; Darrell Divinity-Chicago St. Gregory; Jeff Getz-East Peoria; Dan McCaughey-Quincy Notre Dame; Kevin Meyer-Quincy Notre Dame; Pat Petty-Pittsfield; Dean Pfeiferling-Hamilton; Scott Slocum-East Peoria. |
| 1981 | Mike Siebers-Quincy Notre Dame | Kirk Akrom-Jacksonville; Jerome Birditt-Monmouth; Mel Blasi-Monmouth; Randy Bowman-Northwestern; Mike Elbe-Camp Point Central; Todd Fletcher-Canton; Kirk Francis-Kewanee; Dan McCaughey-Quincy Notre Dame; Kyle Potter-Macomb; Mike Siebers-Quincy Notre Dame. |
| 1980 | Joe Coleman-Lewistown | Scott Bendrick-Canton; Randy Bowman-Northwestern; Joe Coleman-Lewistown; Kirk Francis-Kewanee; Dave Kushner-St. Benedict; John Lubbe-Quincy Notre Dame; Jerry Osinski-St. Benedict; John Rios-Northwestern; David Sweet-Lewistown; Jeff Thorman-Macomb. |
| 1979 | Rocky Owens-Macomb | Pat Blhom-Princeton; Greg Engstrom-Kewanee; Kent Hammond-Monmouth; Greg Havlin-Jacksonville; Greg Jackson-Kewanee; Scott Kalis-Chicago St. Benedict; Scott Kuffel-Kewanee; Rocky Owens-Macomb; Steve Skinner-Monmouth; Jeff Thorman-Macomb. |
| 1978 | Scott Prudhoe-East Peoria | Ron Ballard-East Peoria; Jim Busby-Canton; Craig Cheney-Southeastern; Don Hainline-Sherrard; Rocky Owens-Macomb; Mike Prudhoe-East Peoria; Scott Prudhoe-East Peoria; John Rumley-Princeton; Jeff Sprout-Monmouth; Jeff Stauffer-Pittsfield. |
| 1977 | Dave Anderson-Geneseo | Dave Anderson-Geneseo; Mike Blanks-Kewanee; Tim Higley-Camp Point Central; Lance Hofer-Geneseo; James Jackson-Kewanee; John Medsker-Quincy Notre Dame; Tom Miller-St. Benedict; Bob Paul-Monmouth; Jeff Stauffer-Pittsfield; Mark Taylor-Kewanee. |
| 1976 | Roy Sachse-Fenton-Bensonville | Steve Hopkins-Bushnell-Prairie City; Ron Lindfours-Fenton-Bensonville; Jay McGruder-Macomb; Tim Meckes-Quincy Notre Dame; Jeff Neilson-Camp Point Central; Tom Prusator-Kewanee; Greg Quast-East Peoria; Roy Sachse-Fenton-Bensonville; Jody Shoop-Quincy Notre Dame; Mark Taylor-Kewanee. |
| 1975 | Bart Arthur-Bushnell-Prairie City | Bart Arthur-Bushnell-Prairie City; Mark Brown-Macomb; Dan Dobbins-Pittsfield; James Garry-Fenton-Bensonville; Curt Hogge-Quincy Notre Dame; Mark Wongo-Quincy Notre Dame; Jeff Neilson-Camp Point Central; Roy Sachse-Fenton-Bensonville; Hayes Smith-St. Benedict; Tim Smith-Winchester. |
| 1974 | Robert Middleton-St. Benedict | FIRST TEAM: Brad Bainter-Northwestern; Tim Bresnahan-Monmouth; Robert Middleton-St. Benedict; Kevin Miller-Sherrard; and Steve Scales-St. Benedict; SECOND TEAM: Bart Arthur-Bushnell-Prairie City; Jay Frericks-Quincy Catholic Boys; Al Huffard-Morton; Pete Lazzara-St. Benedict; Mike Reel-Quincy Catholic Boys. |
| 1973 | Tony Moore-Macomb | FIRST TEAM: Jim Gieseman-Rockridge; Tony Moore-Macomb; Jeff Ralph-Peoria Bergan; Bill Ricca-Peoria Bergan; Bill Woodall-Monmouth; SECOND TEAM: Tim Bresnahan-Monmouth; Chris Curran-Quincy Catholic Boys; Jim Kelly-Peoria Bergan; Jerry O’Brien-Pittsfield; Kevin Miller-Sherrard; John Sherrick-Carthage. |
| 1972 | Tony Moore-Macomb | FIRST TEAM: Lou Capps-Pittsfield; Dave Douchant-Dupo; Bill Knaub-Peoria Bergan; Tony Moore-Macomb; John Sherrick-Carthage; SECOND TEAM: Jim Carlson-Peoria Bergan; Rick Conn-Monmouth; Steve Gillenwater-Beardstown; Steve Hawthorne-Macomb; Bill Miller-Bushnell-Prairie City; Joe O’Brien-Macomb; Jeff Ralph-Peoria Bergan. |
| 1971 | Tony Moore-Macomb | FIRST TEAM: Kim Arnett-East Peoria; Bill Miller-Bushnell-Prairie City; Tony Moore-Macomb; Chris Rogge-Beardstown; Jack Wildrick-Carthage; SECOND TEAM: Steve Daniels-Macomb; Al Ferguson-Western High; Greg Frazier-Mendon Unity; Don Haskins-Winchester; Steve McLinden-Peoria Bergan; Jack Stanton-Monmouth. |
| 1970 | Mark Dohner-V.I.T.; Bob Schilcksup-Peoria Bergan | FIRST TEAM: Mark Dohner-V.I.T.; Olie Fosdyck-Macomb; Fred Leuders-East Peoria; Charles Pullins-Monmouth; Bill Schlicksup-Peoria Bergan; SECOND TEAM: Kim Arnett-East Peoria; Denny Brown-Canton; Jim Burling-Carthage; Alex Henseler-Canton; Van Pogue-Western High. |
| 1969 | Tom Howe-Peoria Bergan | FIRST TEAM: Rick Allen-Princeton; Larry Galloway-Peoria Bergan; Tom Howe-Peoria Bergan; Fred Leuders-East Peoria; Laghton McCreary-Chicago Dunbar-and Charles Pullins-Monmouth; SECOND TEAM: Dennis Brown-Canton; Mark Kedzior-Peoria Bergan; Eugene Hinder-Elk Grove; Mike Poole-Chicago Dunbar; Curt Sleers-Mendon Unity. |
| 1968 | Stan Manual-East Peoria | |
| 1967 | Kent Wildrick-Carthage | |
| 1966 | Alan Rose-Bushnell Prairie City | |
| 1965 | Allen Fritschel-Western High | |
| 1964 | Robert Lunt-Rushville | |
| 1963 | Bob Swigris-Spalding | |
| 1962 | Gail Knappenberger-Western High | |
| 1961 | Trevor Toland-Western High | |
| 1960 | Trevor Toland-Western High | |
| 1959 | Larry Hiland-Augusta | |
| 1958 | Larry Krulac-Lewistown | |
| 1957 | Bill Kurz-Quincy Notre Dame | |
| 1956 | John Flynn-Quincy Notre Dame | |
| 1955 | Jim McCaughey-Quincy Notre Dame | |
| 1954 | Gene Morse-Havana | |
| 1953 | Gene Morse-Havana | |
| 1952 | Charles Pittman-Havana | |
